“A man does not call a line crooked unless he has some idea of a straight line. What was I comparing this universe with when I called it unjust?”
— C.S. Lewis
The Lost Art of Fairness
When I was a kid, we’d play football in the street until the streetlights came on. And every so often, someone would shout, “That’s not fair!” Then came the long, heated courtroom of ten-year-olds arguing over whether the ball crossed the line or not. No one ever admitted to being wrong, of course. Everyone was sure they were on the side of justice.
Looking back, that childhood scene feels like a miniature version of our adult world. From family quarrels to workplace politics to the endless courtroom of social media, everyone’s shouting for justice—but hardly anyone seems to know what it means anymore.
C.S. Lewis once said, “A man does not call a line crooked unless he has some idea of a straight line.” That’s the problem—we’ve forgotten where the straight line is. We’ve turned fairness into a feeling, justice into a slogan, and discernment into a lost art.
What follows are five ancient principles of biblical justice—quiet, sturdy truths that cut through the noise. They don’t promise to make conflict easy. But they do make it possible to walk in truth when everyone else is walking in accusation.
1. The Real Root of Conflict Isn’t Disagreement—It’s Desire
We often think conflict starts with differing opinions or competing interests. But Scripture says something far more unsettling:
“What causes fights and quarrels among you? Don’t they come from your desires that battle within you?” — James 4:1
Underneath almost every argument is not an idea problem but a desire problem. It’s envy—an old, sly enemy that wears modern clothes.
You can see it in a nursery. Two toddlers, one toy. The first child doesn’t even notice the toy until the other picks it up. Then suddenly, it’s the most important thing in the room. Adults do the same thing, only our toys are more expensive or more subtle: another person’s respect, platform, peace, or calling.
Envy whispers, “Why them, Lord, and not me?”
And here’s the strange twist: when the person we envy responds with grace, it can make things worse. God “gives grace to the humble,” which means the more they bow low, the more His favor rests on them—and the more our pride flares up. That’s why some conflicts cannot be solved by kindness alone. The problem isn’t niceness; it’s desire.
2. The Ultimate Test for Fairness: Build a Court You’d Be Willing to Stand In
Suppose someone asked you to design a courtroom—but you wouldn’t know whether you’d walk in as the accuser or the accused. How would you build it?
You’d probably make sure it was careful, fair, and slow to condemn. You’d want mercy for the guilty and protection for the innocent. That simple exercise exposes something vital: our sense of justice changes depending on where we stand.
John Rawls called it the “veil of ignorance.” Scripture called it long before that: impartiality.
“Do not show partiality in judging; hear both small and great alike.” — Deuteronomy 1:17
Even mothers know this instinctively when they say, “You cut the pie, your sister picks the slice.”
If we built our judgments—at home, at church, online—as if we didn’t know which side we were on, our world would grow quieter, slower, and infinitely fairer.
3. Most Accusations Should Never Be Heard
Our world is addicted to accusation. We scroll, we click, we forward. But biblical justice insists that most of what passes for “truth-telling” shouldn’t even reach our ears.
God’s law sets three safeguards:
-
No anonymous accusers. Cowards hide behind screens and pen names, but real justice requires a face and a name.
-
No solitary witnesses. A single person’s story can never convict; truth must be confirmed by “two or three witnesses.”
-
Accountability for false charges. If a witness lies, he must suffer the punishment he meant for the other (Deut. 19:19).
Imagine if those rules governed our news feeds. The rumor mill would die in a day.
God’s design here isn’t bureaucratic—it’s merciful. It protects reputations, preserves trust, and prevents the slow murder of slander. When we repeat an unverified claim, we don’t just risk being wrong; we participate in an injustice.
4. The Persecutor’s Blind Spot: They Think They’re the Victim
Rene Girard once said, “Naive persecutors are unaware of what they are doing.” It’s haunting, isn’t it?
When Jesus stood before the high priest, His accusers weren’t cackling villains. They were convinced they were doing God’s work. The high priest tore his robes in righteous anguish, blind to the fact that he was murdering righteousness Himself.
That’s the strange calculus of self-righteousness: it can turn a persecutor into a self-proclaimed hero.
“The time is coming when anyone who kills you will think they are offering a service to God.” — John 16:2
It’s a sobering reminder that sincerity isn’t the same as truth, and feelings of moral outrage aren’t proof of justice. We can crucify the innocent while convinced we’re defending virtue.
5. Why “Trial by Internet” Can Never Be Just
If ever there was a system designed to amplify envy, inflame anger, and reward outrage, it’s the internet.
Social media has become the world’s largest courtroom—without evidence, without judges, and without mercy. Anonymous users hurl accusations. Strangers serve as jury. Algorithms fan the flames. In the end, no one really wins; the truth is trampled in the stampede.
As Doug Wilson puts it in his book A Primer on Justice, this modern mob “circulates its ignorance at high speed.” The whole process is as absurd as “trying to paint a watercolor with your thumbs while wearing wool mittens.”
Justice requires slowness, patience, and proportion. The internet requires the opposite. It rewards speed, emotion, and visibility. No wonder true justice feels impossible in a system built for noise.
A More Deliberate Justice
The older I get, the more I’m convinced justice isn’t about speed but sobriety. It takes wisdom to pause before we post, humility to withhold judgment, and courage to demand evidence before outrage.
The next time you’re tempted to jump into a dispute, try this: design your response as if you might be the one accused. Would you still want it public? Would you still want it fast? Would you still call it fair?
In a noisy world of accusation, the most radical act may simply be to stop, think, and remember the straight line again.
“He has shown you, O man, what is good;
and what does the Lord require of you
but to do justice, to love kindness,
and to walk humbly with your God?”
— Micah 6:8
Soli Deo Gloria
No comments:
Post a Comment